Case study: nonprofit CRM migration

“We didn't know who the who was.”

Nina Portugal Welsh, Lead by Learning

Lead by Learning, a center of Northeastern University in Oakland, moved from CiviCRM to HubSpot with us. Here's what changed.

Book a call

Published . Updated .

Painted scene of teachers talking around classroom desks at sunset, with Lake Merritt and the Tribune Tower in Oakland through the windows
Part of
Northeastern University
Where
Oakland, California
Type
Nonprofit, education
What we did
CiviCRM to HubSpot migration, team training and partner sales coaching

Who they are

An Oakland nonprofit that helps educators learn from each other.

Lead by Learning builds equity-centered communities of practice for educators.

It began as Mills Teacher Scholars at Mills College. Northeastern University later acquired Mills, and Lead by Learning is now a center of Northeastern on its Oakland campus.

They lift up students that schools often leave out, like students with IEPs, multilingual learners and BIPOC students.

In 2024, their work reached more than 600 education leaders and 430,000 students.

Before

Hunches, spreadsheets and a CRM nobody used.

Lead by Learning is a team of self-described “scrappy educators.” They ran on Google Sheets and Google Docs. Their content was spread across Mailchimp, Flickr, Canva and several social accounts.

Then their programs grew past the San Francisco Bay Area. Schools, districts, county offices and other nonprofits started reaching out from around the country.

They tried CiviCRM to keep track of everyone. It's free and open source, which many nonprofits like. But the team found it hard to use. It ate staff time and needed ongoing tech support.

They were missing chances to grow partner relationships and reach their goals.

Nina on “a million spreadsheets” (1:01)

“We had created lots of systems to do the job that a database does 10 times faster and 10 times smoother.”

Nina Portugal Welsh, Director of Visibility and Community Engagement, Lead by Learning

“Our team was really struggling with [CiviCRM] and it was slowing us down versus helping us out. And so we knew something had to change.”

Nina Portugal Welsh, Director of Visibility and Community Engagement, Lead by Learning

What we did

We listened first. Then we moved them to HubSpot.

We looked for the root of the problem before we touched any software.

  1. Looked at how they worked. We mapped their systems, their daily work and their goals.

  2. Helped them pick the right tools. We compared CRM and content options with them. HubSpot won because the team found it easy to use, and it keeps contacts, marketing, content and service in one place.

  3. Set goals they could measure. We defined KPIs and goals together, so they could report on their progress.

  4. Moved them off CiviCRM. We moved them to HubSpot and set up simple processes that everyone agreed to follow.

  5. Trained the team at their pace. We ran onboarding and training, and wrote how-to guides for everyday jobs like social posting.

“He helped us remember that we're not just investing in software.”

Nina Portugal Welsh, Director of Visibility and Community Engagement, Lead by Learning

Dan's advice, in Nina's words, was to “clean your closet first, assess what you have.”

Nina on how we listened first (2:19)

Ew, sales!

Nonprofits sell too. They just call it something else.

Many nonprofits don't like the word “sales.” Their partners aren't customers, and the work isn't only about money.

But fundraising, donor development and grant writing are sales. So is bringing a new partner into your programs.

We made words like “pipeline,” “funnel” and “qualified lead” feel less scary. Then we coached the team to use those ideas with partners and future partners.

“He gave us vocabulary we had never seen or used before… now we sit in meetings and we're like, so what are our MQLs and our SEO?”

Nina Portugal Welsh, Director of Visibility and Community Engagement, Lead by Learning
Nina on sales for nonprofits (1:20)

“We have had one of our strongest sales seasons. We're working with more partners than ever before. And I do think there's been a lot of ease to that because of HubSpot.”

Nina Portugal Welsh, Director of Visibility and Community Engagement, Lead by Learning

They also sent out more scopes of work than ever before.

Before and after

What changedBeforeAfter
Partner survey responseBefore: About 50 to 60%, their best guessAfter: 88% of more than 600 partner educators
LinkedIn followersBefore: 190After: 430
Sending a marketing emailBefore: HoursAfter: A few minutes
One social postBefore: 45 minutes to an hourAfter: Planned and posted from one calendar
Where their data livedBefore: Google Sheets, Google Docs, Mailchimp, Flickr and CanvaAfter: HubSpot
What they knew about readersBefore: Who downloaded a resource, and nothing moreAfter: Who clicked, what they read and what they downloaded

How it played out

Seeing who reads what.

With CiviCRM, they could see who downloaded a resource. That was where it stopped.

In HubSpot, they see who clicks, which blog posts they read and which free resources they take. They put a banner in each of their 10 most-read posts, and every click is tracked.

Their emails got shorter too. A free playbook download sent an automated email with three links, and people clicked only one. So they wrote a shorter email with just that link, and it now gets far more clicks.

“I can look back and say, oh, wow, they downloaded that resource in October. They came to a webinar in February. Now I can start to personalize a message to them. And they're not just a principal in Connecticut, right? They have a connection to us and I can tell they're clearly value aligned to what we're trying to do.”

Nina Portugal Welsh, Director of Visibility and Community Engagement, Lead by Learning
Nina on “we didn't know who the who was” (1:23)

LinkedIn, almost every day.

Writing posts in Google Docs and copying them to each network could take 45 minutes to an hour. The team called it the “most expensive hour of our organization.”

Now they plan and post to every network from HubSpot's social calendar. They learned that district and school leaders use LinkedIn most, so they post there almost daily.

Their LinkedIn followers more than doubled, from 190 to 430. Allied groups repost them more than ever.

Nina on keeping content in one place (1:18)

An 88% survey response.

Lead by Learning surveys its partners at the start and end of each school year to measure its impact.

In past years the data was shaky, and getting answers meant a lot of chasing. Their best guess was that 50 to 60% of partners replied.

They ran the survey in HubSpot Service Hub, so it was easy to build. HubSpot nudged people who hadn't taken it yet, so facilitators no longer had to email each teacher one by one.

88% of more than 600 partner educators answered.

“This year, our survey had an 88% take rate of our partners, which is unbelievable.”

Nina Portugal Welsh, Director of Visibility and Community Engagement, Lead by Learning
Nina on measuring their impact (1:08)

Nonprofits deserve the startup playbook too.

We bring the expertise and technology that's working at fast-growing startups, in words that fit your mission. Book a 30-minute call, and we'll tell you honestly if we can help.

We are a HubSpot and Aircall partner and may earn a fee when you buy through us. We recommend them only when they fit.